Work Package 1.2 - Water resources and flood risk management
River basins support nature, human life and economies in many ways, however, problems arising from agricultural and urban land use and, increasingly, climate change pose a range of management challenges. Pressures on our catchments include organic and inorganic pollution, flow and morphology alteration, flood risk, surface and groundwater abstraction, land use change, climate variability and change, invasive species and pathogens. There is a need to understand how these pressures affect the biophysical and ecological processes within our catchments. This RD focuses on understanding how the biophysical and ecological processes within water bodies operate and contribute to the delivery of ecosystem functions and health.
The Water Framework Directive (WFD) requires targeted measures to improve ecological status whilst the Habitats Directive requires that water Special Areas of Conservation attain and maintain Favourable Condition. There is an ongoing need for SEPA’s monitoring strategy for River Basin Management and the strategic research to be underpinned by effective statistical methods and associated sampling and instrumentation. Coupled with this, the EU Floods Directive (FD) requires governments to adopt, where possible, a sustainable approach to flood risk management. Natural flood management (NFM) is a sustainable approach to flood risk management being adopted in the Scotland, however, there is not enough evidence for the effectiveness of the various measures to allow it to be fully utilised by practitioners. RD 1.2.1. is contributing to key research evidence and synthesis in areas identified by SEPA, Scottish Government and the Environment Agency and driven by legislation pertaining to the WFD, Nitrates Directive, Drinking Water Directive, Flood Directive and Habitats Directive.
Aim of Research
To understand how pressures such as problems arising from agricultural and urban land use and, increasingly, climate change affect the biophysical and ecological processes within our catchments. The focus of the research is on understanding how the biophysical and ecological processes within water bodies operate and contribute to the delivery of ecosystem function and health. The core of this work will provide information and knowledge that is needed to address one of the fundamental research questions of the programme (How do Scotland’s natural assets function, how healthy are they, what are their trends, and what are ‘safe’limits to their sustainable use) and the issues of change, adaptation and management which are covered in other parts of the programme.
Field work and data collection continues to underpin catchment-based research. Monitoring of riparian buffer strips continues to show differential soil nitrate availability and nitrous oxide emissions between buffer strips with different plant community structures. Buffer strips dominated by grasses tend to emit more greenhouse gasses than those with a wider range of species including dicots. Studies at two river restoration sites are establishing a strong evidence base for the benefits of floodplain reconnection, re-meandering & dead-wood placements. The Beltie Burn study has achieved the data threshold required for effective statistical evaluation, representing one of the most comprehensive evaluations of a restoration project in Scotland; the groundworks for the restoration will be undertaken this summer. The Logie Burn monitoring dataset was updated and seven years post-restoration, the stream has gained sediment and pool habitat.
A novel application of a statistical method for analysing stream water quality time series has been developed. This has been shown to improve the prediction of stream sediment phosphorus from high frequency turbidity measurements. We have also analysed stream and source samples for tracers which represent both soil and vegetation characteristics and can be used to indicate the sources of stream sediments. The application of source tracking methods to the National Waters Inventory DNA archive was completed and whole-genome sequencing carried out on ~500 E. coli isolates from Tarland sub-catchment sampling. River sampling campaigns have been conducted and samples were measured for emerging contaminants.
- Flood risk scientists co-develop an international workshop in Edinburgh. Working with SEPA, EA and Scottish Government, SEFARI scientists co-organised the international Nature Based Solutions (NBS) symposium in Edinburgh on May 2019. The event consisted of keynote speeches, including an opening address by Rosanna Cunningham, field trips and workshop sessions. The aim was to share international best practice around implementing NBS measures within catchments and on coasts to reduce flood risk and provide wider ecosystem services. Over 90 participants attended from 14 countries.
- Collaboration strengthened with applied research in Ireland. SEFARI researchers presented multiple aspects of RESAS-funded research at the Catchment Science 2019 Conference (Wexford, November 2019), including modelling of phosphorus sources and mitigation; the F-MAPT tool to enable placement of flood mitigation measures; riparian management; water payment for ecosystem services and soil erosion work . Researchers are working closely with the Teagasc Institute and the Irish EPA in riparian and Natural Flood Management (NFM) allied research projects with mutual benefit for the land.
We continue to monitor within our catchment experiments at a variety of scales. Evidence collected from this RD has been published in international books and high impact scientific papers. A summary paper has been published highlighting how Natural Flood Management helps to mitigate flood flows at the local scale but highlights challenges and future directions for upscaling the approach to larger catchments and larger events. New statistical methods have led to improved understanding of the relationships between river flows and sediment and phosphorus in rivers. Also, research continues to take place on microbial source tracking by culture dependent and independent approaches which is key to understanding where faecal pollution is being generated and what and who is required to mitigate it. Research continues to investigate the occurrence and behaviour of emerging contaminants by developing monitoring and detection methods towards eventual improved modelling capabilities.
- Scaling up Natural Flood Management: A summary paper has been written which highlights how NFM can help to mitigate flood peaks at the local scale through two case study examples. The issue of upscaling to large catchment areas is also discussed.
- Buffer strips seminar: A presentation was given by a SEFARI scientist at the Chartered Institute of Water and Environmental Managers (CIWEM) diffuse pollution conference, London, 18-19th July entitled ‘Rethinking Buffer Strips in 3-Dimensions’ including international co-authors, EA and Forest Research (available here). The talk discusses how we can optimise the traditional grassed buffer strip to deliver more ecosystem services.
- Bowmont research features in international book: The Bowmont catchment research has been recently summarised in a chapter of an international book published by the US Army Corp of Engineers. The book is called "Engineering with Nature: An Atlas" and gives an visual overview of natural flood management measures including tree planting and use of novel wooden structures in the catchment case study.
- Presentation on turbidity: A paper presented at the 3rd International Workshop on High Temporal Resolution Water Quality Monitoring and Analysis (Clonakilty, Ireland) detailed statistical methods developed to look for ‘states’ (indicative of periods when changes occur in dominant controlling factors) in river monitoring data. The techniques improve how we use in-situ turbidity sensors to derive river sediment time-series using data from the Lunan catchment, Scotland, in a collaboration between researchers at James Hutton Institute and BioSS.
- DNA approaches for understanding river microbial pollutants: A large database of E. coli isolates from NE Scotland catchment (livestock faeces-derived from soils, streamwaters, sediments) are completing being genetically sequenced to evaluate strains/characteristics passed from livestock to waters and help develop mitigation. Antimicrobial resistance gene profiles from 50 of the isolates are showing novel multi-drug resistance.
This RD continues to provide empirical evidence to real world problems via applied research in catchments. These include assessing the impact of Natural Flood Management actions managing flood peaks using landscape water retention and in-stream techniques, to the identification of emerging contaminants using microbial (e.g. antimicrobial resistance genes) and chemical analyses (pesticides and pharmaceuticals). Scientific summaries from the Bowmont catchment have appeared in National documents which have been promoted by UK policy. Data and analysis in this RD have been supporting the production of high-quality scientific publications. Work on pathogens continues to improve our understanding of sources of specific target pathogens, not just indicator organisms, leading to improved environmental source-tracking, behaviour knowledge and eventually management. Continued research is closely being discussed with stakeholders (e.g. SEPA, SG) through mechanisms such as the flooding and diffuse pollution working groups.
- Effect of Agriculture on the Environment: A set of special sessions at the Land Use and Water Quality Conference in the Hague in June 2017 were organised by the James Hutton Institute and Aarhus University. Presentations included work on buffer strip management, and will appear in a special collection of scientific papers in the Journal of Environmental Quality. Key highlights included the need for engagement with farmers to ensure effective mitigation measures.
- Emerging contaminants assessed in a Scottish river and coastal waters: The annual flux and risk of emerging contaminants were estimated for a Scottish priority catchment (River Ugie) and to the adjacent estuary and North Sea and a research paper on this topic has been published.
- Natural flood management in the Bowmont Water highlighted as a national case study: Outputs from the Bowmont Natural Flood Management study have featured as a case study in the recently published “Working with natural processes: evidence directory” (produced by the Environment Agency).
- SRP research on multiple benefits of riparian buffer strips is developing international collaboration: Developed expertise examining riparian functions (pollutant mitigation, habitat, flood benefits and improving riparian condition and resilience) in Scotland has led to WP1.2 researchers partnering Irish researchers on a 4-year buffer design and placement project (Irish EPA funded; 2018-22) involving KE with Scottish stakeholders (SEPA, SNH) and another buffer design contract with the EA.
This RD has maintained continuity in evidence gathering and tool development around catchment studies in both research sites and 'real world' catchments. An example is the Tarland research catchment (headwater of the River Dee) being used to develop the partnership approaches for Natural Flood Management and morphological improvements and long term RESAS-funded catchment datasets have been uploaded onto NERC's open access datacentre. The River Dee has provided a large river context for integration of research evidence into environmental decision making (supporting the development of ecological monitoring for river restoration assessment, post flooding management responses). As a technical assessment and demonstration site we have used Balruddery farm to evaluate riparian and field-edge buffer management experiments to investigate multiple benefits of nutrient retention and cycling, biomass generation and habitat imnprovement set in the context of a working farm with demonstration examples utilising the industry events often hosted there. New tool development has focussed on methods for emerging water contaminants (using and developing techinques for organic chemicals reported in a Nature journal in 2017) and on environmental tracers for sediments and pathogens. The data collected in this RD underpins the modelling in RD1.2.2.
- Collaboration between JHI, CEH and SEPA (Willie Duncan) has resulted in closer integration of activities within RESAS WP1.2 and SEPA’s river restoration pilot program.
- A paper on integrating the requirements of the Floods Directive and Water Framework Directive was presented to the European Commission Common Implementation Strategy.
- A paper has been published in Nature: Ecology and Evolution, as part of international collaboration. The paper reports extraordinary levels of organic pollutants that persist in the endemic amphipod fauna from two ocean trenches. The study uses techniques developed in WP1.2 and reports contaminant levels were considerably higher than documented for nearby regions of heavy industrialization, indicating bioaccumulation of anthropogenic contamination. Jamieson et al. 2017 Nature: Ecology and Evolution.
- RESAS work supported post-flood surveys of Storm Frank on the River Dee aiming to evaluate the scale of change and management lessons for future large floods (in Partnership with SEPA, Aberdeenshire and City Councils and MDT)
Work continues on our farm sites and research catchments in continuing to develop an evidence base for Natural Flood Management (NFM) and water quality measures. Hydrology, hydrochemistry, sediment and habitat quality are being assessed across the River Dee and Lunan in farmed landscapes. Assessment of buffer strips at the Balruddery farm and in Tarland is continuing. Peri-urban expansion effects on water quality in Elsick is also being assessed. Morphologcal change in relation flooding is being assessed in the upper River Dee and Bowmont Water. These studies contribute to our long term understanding of processes and environmental change, support development of new techniques (in-situ sensors and pollution source tracing methods), allow us to integrate with on-the-ground stakeholders, follow management and take part in national strategies (for example Environmental Data Platforms).
Plans for evaluation of improvements in habitat and ecological functioning following river restoration are developing in north-east Scotland rivers. Pre- and post-intervention surveys of morphology, ecology and habitat will facilitate rigorous scientific assessment of the restoration now being realised for a lower tributary of the River Dee (Beltie Burn). Another tributary that has been monitored since restoration in 2011 (Logie Burn) will be surveyed again to allow a nine-year assessment of morphological and physical habitat change. On the upper River Dee, 5 years of hydrological data are being used to measure the impacts of floodplain restoration and monitoring is continuing.
Sediment pollution sources, the behaviour in-stream and pollution carrying capacity of the sediments are key factors in river quality. Sediments also allow strong science links to catchment stakeholders since sediments are a very visual sign of river health, are related to actions on soil erosion and unite the mitigation measures combating pollution with water-sediment retention measures that form part of NFM. One area of ongoing work looks at the utility of high frequency turbidity time-series data for assessing sediment delivery and new ways to query complex datasets and learn about system behaviour and transferability of calibrations of turbidity against wider parameters of interest (e.g. phosphorus). Another area is developing tracers to identify sediment sources based on patterns of organic matter imparted by the vegetation that can provide information on the influence of land cover and management on erosion.
Our emerging contaminants assessment work looks at microbial and organic chemical threats to water quality. Both groups of pollutants suffer from weak evidence for the occurrence and behaviour of directly-measured pathogens and chemicals and complex arrays of breakdown products in the environment. Ongoing microbial work is developing libraries of DNA analysed from water and environmental sources to compare to conventional monitoring via faecal indicator organisms, assess the prevalence of certain antimicrobial resistance genes and inform better source management. Work between the James Hutton Institute and Moredun Research Institute focusses on both E. Coli and Cryptosporidium and the data generated are starting to allow better catchment pathogen modelling. The presence of chemical contaminants of pesticides, pharmaceuticals are being assessed in sites in the River Dee, building on previous work in the River Ugie and being combined into risk assessments of exposure across freshwater to coastal systems.
- Nesshover et al. (2016) The science, policy and practice of nature-based solutions: An interdisciplinary perspective (link is external). Science of The Total Environment, 579, pp.1215-1227. This was discussed in the Nature editorial ‘‘Nature-based solutions’ is the latest green jargon that means more than you might think(link is external)’.
- Addy, S.; Wilkinson, M. (2016) An assessment of engineered log jam structures in response to a flood event in an upland gravel-bed river system (link is external). Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 41, pp.1658-1670.
- Zhang, Z.L. et al. (2016) Evaluation of spot and passive sampling for monitoring, flux estimation and risk assessment of pesticides within the constraints of a typical regulatory monitoring scheme (link is external). Science of The Total Environment, 569-570, pp.1369-1379.
- Wilkinson, M. et al. (2017) Evaluating performance and placement of nature-based solutions in peri-urban environments for achieving multiple benefits (Session PS2. Integrated water management through natural systems). At: ‘Nature-Based Solutions. From Innovation to Common-Use (link is external) 24-26 October 2017, Tallinn, Estonia.
- Neil, A.J. et al. (2018). Using spatial-stream-network models and long-term data to understand and predict dynamics of faecal contamination in a mixed land-use catchment(link is external). Science of the Total Environment, 612, pp.840-852.
- Stutter, M. et al. (2017). Evaluating the use of in-situ turbidity measurements to quantify fluvial sediment and phosphorus concentrations and fluxes in agricultural streams. (link is external) Science of the Total Environment, 607-608, pp.391-402.
- Zhang Z.L. et al. (2017). Risk Estimation and Annual Fluxes of Emerging Contaminants from a Scottish Priority Catchment to the Estuary and North Sea(link is external). Environmental Geochemistry and Health, 40, pp.1987-2005.
- Stutter, M. et al. (2018) Rethinking buffer strips in three-dimensions (link is external). Presentation at the CIWEM Diffuse Pollution: Policy and Practice conference, London. The work presented detailed the integration of ideas across RESAS, EA, Danish and Irish EPA funded initiatives.
- Bowmont catchment research summarised in chapter ‘Bowmont Catchment Initiative’ of "Engineering with Nature: An Atlas (link is external)". Bridges, T. S. et al. (2018) Engineering With Nature: an atlas. U.S. Army Engineer Research and Development Center.
- Vinten, A. et al. (2018). Analysis of turbidity time series data from the Lunan Water catchment, Scotland, using Hidden Markov chains (link is external). Presentation at 3rd International Workshop on High Temporal Resolution Water Quality Monitoring and Analysis, Teagasc Agricultural College, Clonakilty, Co. Cork, Ireland, 12-13th June, 2018.
- Teagasc, IST; Pagaling, E.; Abel, C.; Avery, L.; Belgrade, University of Surrey, City Analysts Ltd, GPS, Desing, Fruit and Veggies 'Suitability of novel technologies for determining irrigation, processing and bottled water quality(link is external)' Technical report for the European Commission CORDIS Project, Aquavalens, Cluster 3, WP12: Food production - Water used in Food Processing and Bottled Waters
- Pagaling, E. (2018) Molecular methods for pathogen detection. Aquavalens (link is external) (Protecting the health of Europeans by improving methods for the detection of pathogens in drinking water and water used in food preparation) Dissemination Workshop, Broadway House, London, 16 May 2018. Oral presentation.
- Zhang, Z.L. et al. (2018) Monitoring strategy, annual fluxes and risk assessment of emerging contaminants in a catchment scale. Presentation at Emerging pollutants in freshwater ecosystems. Water JPI 2018 Conference, 6–7th of June 2018, Helsinki, Finland (link is external)
- Wilkinson, M.E. et al. 2019. Natural flood management: small-scale progress and larger-scale challenges. Scottish Geographical Journal, 135(1-2), pp.23-32.
- Addy, S. and Wilkinson, M.E., 2019. Geomorphic and retention responses following the restoration of a sand-gravel bed stream. Ecological Engineering, 130, pp.131-146.
- Nicholson, A.R.; O'Donnell, G.M.; Wilkinson, M.E.; and Quinn, P.F. 2020. The potential of runoff attenuation features as a Natural Flood Management approach. Journal of Flood Risk Management, 13, p.e12565.
- Dimitrova‐Petrova, K.; Geris, J.; Wilkinson, M.E.; Lilly, A. and Soulsby, C., 2020. Using isotopes to understand the evolution of water ages in disturbed mixed land‐use catchments. Hydrological Processes, 34(4), pp.972-990.
- Wilkinson, M.; Stutter, M. and Quinn, P. 2019, January. The role of multifunctional Nature Based Solution zones in intensively managed agricultural systems: re-evaluating edge of field measures. In Geophysical Research Abstracts (Vol. 21). Invited presentation.
- Stutter, M.I.; Wilkinson, JM.; Baggaley, N.; Ó Huallacháin, D.; Mellander, P.E.; Nisbet, T.; Letts, J.; Effective targeting of novel riparian buffer designs. Land Use and Water Quality (LuWQ 2019) Conference, Agriculture and the Environment, Aarhus, Denmark, 3-6 June 2019.
- Zak, D.; Stutter, M.; Jensen, H.S.; Egemose, S.; Carstensen, M.V.; Audet, J.; Strand, J.A.; Feuerbach, P.; Hoffmann, C.C.; Christen, B. and Hille, S. 2019. An assessment of the multifunctionality of integrated buffer zones in northwestern Europe. Journal of environmental quality, 48(2), pp.362-375.
- Roberts, W.M.; George, T.S.; Stutter, M.I.; Louro, A.; Ali, M. and Haygarth, P.M. Effects of the roots of different grass species on phosphorus leaching from riparian soils with differing management histories and biogeochemical conditions. Plant and Soil. In Press.
- Cole, L.J.; Stockan, J. and Helliwell, R., 2020. Managing riparian buffer strips to optimise ecosystem services: A review. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 296, p.106891.
- Cui, S.; Hough, R.; Yates, K.; Osprey, M.; Kerr, C.; Cooper, P.; Coull, M. and Zhang, Z., 2020. Effects of season and sediment-water exchange processes on the partitioning of pesticides in the catchment environment: Implications for pesticides monitoring. Science of The Total Environment, 698, p.134228.